Ben Nye Cake Eye Liner Refill

I bought two colors of this eyeliner in Eggplant and Black. I bought the refills to put in my Z palette. I also bought the Ben Nye LiquiSet Mixing Liquid. The Eggplant is a rich, deep reddish tone, but really a good alternative to the usual black and brown, as it makes my blues eyes pop! I am really impressed with the liners and the setting liquid. Using water only, you don't get the depth of color I like, but with the LiquiSet, you get a deep, beautiful, long lasting eyeliner, that goes on like a liquid eyeliner. It hardly smudges at all, and stays on all day. It is so easy to apply and work with!! I have had many problems with any kind of eye liner, including pencil, gel, or cake, smudging on me almost immediately, and irritating my eyes. This is great, and does not irritate my sensitive eyes or bother my contact lenses.

Good product, recommending using the liquid set with it.

I love the cake eyeliner but I don't like that it is not waterproof. During allergy season my eyes water and it's all over my eyelid.

I wanted to try something new because sometimes I have a hard time trying to use gel liner. I can truly say this product is better for me.