Black Cake Mascara 1920 - Refill
This + Krylon Sealer = Perfect
I only wear makeup once a month or so, which means that tubes of mascara are something of a waste. This solved the spoilage problem.
It absolutely must be used with the Krylon Cake Eyeliner Sealer. I tried it with Cinema Secrets and had no luck. With the Krylon, I've got at least ten hours of wear with no flaking.
I apply with a spoolie. Cinema Secrets brush cleaner gets the spoolie clean. Cleansing balm + cream cleanser gets everything off my lashes.